The top three prize winners of Retro Chronicle’s 2014 Retro Pumpkin Contest


Fall is my favorite season, because it’s marked by several of my favorite traditions– one of which is carving pumpkins. Last year and for the first time in many years, I decided to visit a local pumpkin patch to pick up a couple orange guards to carve. It took me a while to decide on what to carve, but I finally decided on Ash’s Squirtle from the Squirtle Squad Pokemon episodes. It was important to me to set time aside to do something fun and creative and share my creation with friends.

This October marked the first Halloween since Retro Chronicle was created. So I wanted to do something fun to showcase some creative people and get the word out about this site. Many social media contests simply involve reposting an image or sharing a page a certain number of times. But to me, that is a little spammy and unimaginative. So a pumpkin carving contest felt perfect.

This contest took place on Instagram, which is a nostalgic platform in itself with its vintage filters and Throwback Thursdays. The rules were simple:

  1. Carve or decorate a pumpkin with a retro or nostalgia theme.
  2. Upload a picture of your creation to Instagram.
  3. Tag us (@retrochronicle) in the post and add the hashtag #retropumpkincontest.
  4. Tell us (about 3-5 sentences) about how and why you carved the pumpkin this way.

All submissions were carefully considered by myself and everyone who’s ever contributed to this website. We judged our contestants on a variety of criteria, including the detail and precision of the carving, the story behind it, and the nostalgic conversation that they sparked. Here are the first, second and third place winners:


First place: Frankie Torres’s Samus pumpkin

The contributors of Retro Chronicle (about five of us) had a difficult time picking the winners of this contest, but we all agreed that Frankie had some of the most creative and detailed entries. In addition to this Metroid-inspired carving, he also crafted two others– one incredible, 3-D Yoshi pumpkin and an equally-impressive Metal Gear-inspired pumpkin.

This is what Frankie had to say about his entry: “Samus seemed like the perfect subject for my pumpkin. I drew the eyes and nose on tracing paper and placed it inside behind a sheet of green flash gel. I lit the inside with my phone’s flashlight.”

His prize is a large box full of awesome, retro goodies, including: World of Nintendo Legend of Zelda and Super Mario action figures, classic story books on 7-inch vinyl records, Game Boy games, NES manuals, an antique Kodak Instant Camera and a Tiger Electronic Pinball game.



Second place: Nfalax’s Shy Guy pumpkin

When I spoke to the other Retro Chronicle contributors about who should win, all of them mentioned that they loved this Shy Guy pumpkin. This Instagram user obviously has a deep fascination. Nfalax also submitted a great Bowser pumpkin.

Shy Guys are timid troublemakers in the Super Mario Bros series, famous for the masks they wear as seen in this pumpkin. They made their debut in Super Mario Bros 2 for the NES. Both the second and third place winner of this contest will get free downloads of their choice for the Wii U or 3DS.



Third place: Cheyenne Reindel’s Luigi’s Mansion Pumpkin

This pumpkin was chosen by IGersNintendo, which was this year’s guest judge. The creator of IGersNintendo (which you can follow on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram) played a big role in promoting the contest, getting the word out and deciding on the winners. This is what they had to say about our third place prize winner:

“I have to give this person a lot of credit for sticking two characters onto a pumpkin. That must of took a lot of effort and time to do. Overall, the user does give a great feeling of the Halloween spirit.”


I would like to thank everyone who participated in this contest! I was a little skeptical about doing this contest, because I wasn’t sure enough people would want to participate. But by the end of the month, over 40 submissions had poured in from dozens of creative people. Due to the success of this contest, I hope to host another pumpkin carving contest next year!

Stay tuned tomorrow, because I’m going to showcase ten of my other favorite retro or nostalgia-themed pumpkins that were submitted into this contest this year.

· · ·